| FILMS | PREMIERES | CONVERSATIONS | INSTALLATIONS | ||||||||||||||||||||||
| Peristence
Resistance
2012 9 - 17 February 2012, Delhi |
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
An attempt at bringing together the documentary, the
documentary filmmaker and the audience to collectively
create and define public cultures.
The
5th
edition
of Persistence
Resistance will screen award winning, rarely
seen films, and present a myriad ways of engaging
with them.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
| WORLD PREMIERES | ||||||||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
| CONVERSATIONS | ||||||||||||||||||||||
Sanjay Kak in conversation with director Amlan Datta Anupama Srinivasan in conversation with director Kersti Uibo Bhaskar Sarkar in conversation with director Mamta Murthy and producer Madhusree Dutta Detailed Q&A with director Sameera Jain, moderated by Ira Bhaskar Rahul Roy in conversation with director R. V. Ramani Panel discussion with director Mario Rutten on his film Living Like a Common Man Panelists: Nivedita Ghosh and Dr. Sanjay Srivastava Other Cinemas in India: Production and Piracy, Circulation and Censorship A Panel Discussion following the Premiere of Fried Fish, Chicken Soup and a Premiere Show at the Arts Faculty, Delhi University North Campus Panelists: Lawrence Liang, Ravi Sundaram and director Mamta Murthy. Moderator: Brinda Bose Filmmakers to be present for post-screening Q&A Avijit Mukul Kishore, Gouri Patwardhan, Ishani K. Dutta, Kersti Uibo, Mamta Murthy, Merajur Rahman Baruah, Minnie Vaid, Nakul Singh Sawhney, Nitin K Pamnani, Paranjoy Guha Thakurta, Pradip Saha, R. V. Ramani, Sameera Jain, Sarnath Banerjee, Sohaila Kapur, Sujata Kulshreshtha. Dr. Vandana Shiva will speak following the screening of Bitter Seeds, with director Micha X. Peled joining in on skype. |
||||||||||||||||||||||
| REMEMBRANCE | ||||||||||||||||||||||
The festival will pay homage to Lucia Rikaki, Homai Vyarawalla and Tareque Masud- image-makers of immense fortitude. Homage to Lucia Rikaki by Magic Lantern Homage to Homai Vyarawalla by Sabeena Gadihoke Homage to Tareque Masud by Shohini Ghosh |
||||||||||||||||||||||
| INSTALLATIONS | ||||||||||||||||||||||
Curated by Rattanamol Singh Johal, Presented in collaboration with Khoj-IFA at Queens Gallery, British Council A Visual tribute to Homai Vyarawalla by Sabeena Gadihoke at India International Centre |
||||||||||||||||||||||
| VIDEO PARLOURS and VIDEO LIBRARY | ||||||||||||||||||||||
Dedicated video parlours will present curated selections from film archives of: Deutsche Film-Aktiengesellschaft (DEFA), Germany and Public Diplomacy Division, Ministry of External Affairs, India |
||||||||||||||||||||||
| DATES and
VENUES |
||||||||||||||||||||||
9 - 11 February British Council 17 Kasturba Gandhi Marg, New Delhi 110001 10 February Arts Faculty, Delhi University North Campus Room No. 22 12 - 15 February India International Centre 40 Max Mueller Marg, New Delhi 110003 17 February Goethe-Institut / Max Mueller Bhavan 3 Kasturba Gandhi Marg, New Delhi 110001 |
Facebook Event
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
| ENTRY
FREE,
All
are
Welcome |
||||||||||||||||||||||
| Enquiries: Magic Lantern Foundation; J 1881, Chittaranjan Park, Basement, New Delhi 110019 | T: 9111 26273244, 41605239 | E: persistence.resistance@gmail.com | W: http://www.persistenceresistance.in | ||||||||||||||||||||||
Donation-At:HDFC-A-3-Janakpuri-New-DelhiA/cNo-15581000026895:Details for donation of Amount-Please enter Name* Email * Address*
Monday, February 6, 2012
Sunday, February 5, 2012
US for Monitoring of Burma By-elections
5 Feb The United States has urged Burma to allow local and international monitors at April 1 by-elections, seen as an important step in the country’s democratic transition. Assistant Secretary of State Michael Posner, the top US diplomat specializing on human rights issues, said on Thursday the results of the by-elections would not alter the balance of Burma’s military-dominated Parliament, but were a “way-station” in the democratic transition, leading up to fresh national elections in 2015. The party of opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi will be contesting all 48 seats up for grabs.
Media agencies
Quintanahost to hold a press conference on Feb. 5.
5 Feb UN’s special envoy to Burma, Tomás Ojea Quintana, visited Rangoon’s notorious Insein Prison on Friday morning and met with pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi in the afternoon.
Aye Win, a spokesperson for the UN Information Center in Rangoon, told media on Friday that the UN special rapporteur on human rights in Burma observed prison condition at Insein.
Other sources said that Quintana met with several prisoners of conscience while in Insein.
“He also met with the Myanmar National Human Rights Commission and then held another meeting with Daw Aung San Suu Kyi,” said Aye Win.
Quintana told reporters after meeting with Suu Kyi that he will try to push for a constitutional amendment in the framework of Parliament.
However, he did not disclose any details of his meeting with Suu Kyi, but said that he will host a press conference before he leaves Burma on Feb. 5. He also met with some officials in Naypyidaw.
It was reported that during his trip to Burma, the UN envoy planned to visit ethnic Karen and Mon states in order to observe human rights conditions.
On Thursday, Quintana met with Shwe Mann, the speaker of the Lower House of Parliament in the Burmese capital. According to Rangoon-based Popular Journal, he was told by Shwe Mann that the by-election in April will be free and fair,
Quintana met with Suu Kyi and visited Insein Prison during a previous trip to Burma in August. He also took the opportunity to sit in on a parliamentary session attended by MPs from both Upper and Lower Houses. At the time, he said he welcomed the progress made by the new government, and called for the release of political prisoners.
Quintana had been a vocal critic of the previous military regime and previously proposed a UN Commission of Inquiry to investigate war crimes and crimes against humanity that have allegedly been committed by the Burmese army.
Saturday, February 4, 2012
Burma foreign debt US$ 11 billion
Burma's national debt was estimated at $7.37 billion in 2009. While
its finances are currently in shambles, an IMF report in January said
Burma could be Southeast Asia’s next financial frontier, because of its
vast energy resources and untapped work force, many of whom speak
English. China had lent Burma the most in the post-1988 era, at about $2 billion, the minister was quoted as saying.Burma owes more than US$ 11 billion in foreign debt in loans that were
made prior to 1988, its finance minister told Parliament this week.
India Shows Interest for Cooperation with Portugal
India Shows Interest for Cooperation with Portugal
in Wave and off-Shore Energy
Minister of Agriculture, Environment, Sea and Spatial Planning of
Portugal, Mrs. Assuncao Cristas met Minister of New & Renewable
Energy Dr. Farooq Abdullah in New Delhi today. The two sides discussed
possibilities of enhancing cooperation between the two countries in the
field of renewable energy. The Portuguese Minister highlighted the
progress made by her country in renewable energy especially bio-mass and
bio-fuels. She said that in view of high consumption of electricity,
Portugal is now focusing on energy conservation efforts and improving
energy efficiency.
Dr. Abdullah underlined the progress made by India in wind and solar energy. He said India would like to cooperate with Portugal in wave and off-shore energy. Dr. Abdullah also suggested that private sectors of both the countries should cooperate in promoting Renewable Energy in the two countries and offered to provide all possible assistance in this direction. Mrs. Assuncao Cristas invited a delegation from India to see the developments in Portugal in renewable energy with a view to enhance cooperation between the two countries in the area.
Dr. Abdullah underlined the progress made by India in wind and solar energy. He said India would like to cooperate with Portugal in wave and off-shore energy. Dr. Abdullah also suggested that private sectors of both the countries should cooperate in promoting Renewable Energy in the two countries and offered to provide all possible assistance in this direction. Mrs. Assuncao Cristas invited a delegation from India to see the developments in Portugal in renewable energy with a view to enhance cooperation between the two countries in the area.
US travel advisory to citizens to avoid gatherings in Pakistan
US asks citizens to avoid gatherings in Pakistan;
Replacing its previous travel warning dated 8th
April, 2011, the State Department on Thursday asked its citizens to
avoid protests and large gatherings which are happening in Pakistan
after the 26th November cross-border fire.
"There
have been widespread demonstrations and large political rallies
condemning drone strikes and Pakistan's ongoing energy crisis. These
protests are likely to continue. US citizens in Pakistan are strongly
urged to avoid protests and large gatherings," it said.
The
State Department said presence of al-Qaeda, Taliban elements, and
indigenous militant sectarian groups poses a potential danger to US
citizens throughout Pakistan.
Terrorists regularly attack civilians, government, and foreign targets, it said.
"Threat
reporting indicates terrorist groups continue to seek opportunities to
attack locations where US citizens and Westerners are known to
congregate or visit, such as shopping areas, hotels, clubs and
restaurants, places of worship, schools, and outdoor recreation events,"
it said.
"Terrorists
have disguised themselves as Pakistani security personnel to gain
access to targeted areas. Some media reports have falsely identified US
diplomats and to a lesser extent US and other Western journalists and
non-governmental organization workers - as being intelligence operatives
or private security personnel," the alert said. Friday, February 3, 2012
Priyanka hits the campaign trail in Uttar Pradesh
Hitting
the campaign trail in Uttar Pradesh, Congress' star campaigner Priyanka
Gandhi on Friday asked the electorate to realise the strength of their
vote and exercise their franchise for a change in the state.
"Election
is the time when leaders come for electioneering of all kinds...I also
come in your midst but who has the wisdom to recognise the reality of
their candidates and the political parties...you...and take this into
account when you go out to vote", Priyanka said at a public meeting in
Balbhadrapur area of her brother Rahul Gandhi's parliamentary
constituency in Amethi.
"Times
have come when the people are not getting their rights in their areas
.. politics has become bad and become opportunistic and moves ahead only
because of division of your vote", she said adding people and not
leaders should be standing on the dias.
Stressing
that it is wrong that people beg before their leaders, she said that in
the past 22 years it has been caste and religion-based politics in UP
which has been dominating at the cost of development.
Taking a stand similar to her brother, Priyanka said that people from Amethi go out of the state to Maharashtra and Kerala to work as they are developed and now it is time to bring a change Amethi.
She
said the time has come to bring this change and it was not the prestige
of her family nor of the Congress candidates but of the future of their
families and their children.
"If Congress is strengthened and its government is formed in UP, it would would develop", she said.
She
said that situation has come to such a pass when parties have to
introduce their candidates and specifically mention that they have not
committed crimes like murder, not snatched the land of people.
Priyanka would stay in the area for five days.
At
an interaction in Jamu area, Priyanka termed corruption, anarchy and
lack of development as the biggest enemies of the people of Uttar
Pradesh.
"Anarchy,
corruption and opportunism are the biggest enemies of the people of
Uttar Pradesh, not of Rahul Gandhi and they should rise up to change
them (in these elections), Priyanka said when asked as to who is the
main enemy of her party, Mayawati or Mulayam Singh Yadav.
She said people are now fed up and the reality is now dawning that this kind of politics is not working.
NRHM’s Achievements
Better Health Indicators Testimony to NRHM’s Achievements: IAP
The
International Advisory Panel (IAP) on National Rural Health Mission today
attributed India’s better Health Indicators to work accomplished under various
components of NRHM. The panel headed by Prof. Jeffery D. Sachs, Earth
Institute, Columbia and comprising of other experts held meeting with the Union
Health and Family Welfare Minister Shri Ghulam Nabi Azad and senior officials
of the Ministry at New Delhi today.
Chairing
the meeting the Union Health and Family Welfare Minister Shri Ghulam Nabi Azad
noted that NRHM has made substantial progress in its journey of providing
accessible, equitable and affordable health care ever since its launch in 2005.
India’s steady three point decline in the IMR both in 2009 & 2010 and the
fact that decline in rural IMR is greater than the decline in Urban IMR is
noteworthy, the Minister said. He added that stepped up interventions in child
care through implementation of the Home Based New Born Care through ASHAs; incentives for ASHAs for delivering such care
in the rural areas; launch of Janani Shishu Suraksha Karyakaram (JSSK), in
June, 2011 with initiatives stipulating free drugs, free diet, free
diagnostics, and, if required, free blood, besides free transport from home to
institution, between facilities in case of a referral and drop back home for
every pregnant woman and similar entitlements having been put up in place for
all sick neonates accessing public health institutions for treatment have gone
a long way in improving the IMR figures. He stated that the Pulse Polio
programme has had an unprecedented success with India having been Polio free
for past one year. Strengthening the immunization programme, introduction of
second dose of measles; extending Pentavalent vaccine to more States is on the
anvil, the Minister informed.
Shri
Azad informed that with Prime Minister having announced focus on Health in 12th
plan, the Health Ministry has proposed several new initiatives like supply of
free generic drugs to all patients attending public health facilities
throughout the country in attempt to achieve universal health care.
Up-gradation and strengthening of District Hospitals to provide not only
maternal & child health services but also health care for communicable and
non communicable diseases is also high on the agenda, Shri Azad said. “In view
of the significant human resources crunch in our country, priority is accorded
to strengthening of tertiary care centers and expansion of both undergraduate
and postgraduate education to increase the availability of doctors and
specialists to man the several National Programmes that have been launched for
prevention, control, detection and treatment of diseases across the country”
the Minister informed. “The next phase of the NRHM is set to capitalize on this
momentum and, with the proposed National Urban Health Mission, we hope to
accelerate our journey towards the National Health Goals”, the Minister added.
Prof
Jeffery Sachs along with his team of experts, commended India for the
incredible progress but emphasized the need for quarterly data/ real time data
for better programme management as also the need for model distt approach. He
said they are piloting five model districts - one each in Assam, Uttar Pradesh,
Andhra Pradesh, Bihar and Rajasthan, where programs would be implemented in a
focused and integrated manner. Prof Sachs underscored the need for higher
investments in health sector and said that while addressing the need for
tertiary care, investments in the primary care delivery systems should not
become a casualty. He reiterated that primary care systems should be
strengthened so that IMR, MMR and other health indicators can further be
improved. He also said that adequate attention needs to be given to tackle the
under nutrition challenge. Prof Sachs said lessons learnt in India are valuable
for translating the experience world over. Other experts while appreciating the
initiative emphasized on capacity building, health promotion and preventive health
care and need for introduction of new vaccines besides strengthening the
community process.
Summing
up the discussions, Secretary H&FW Shri P K Pradhan said the Ministry is
making use of the Health Management Information System to gather real time data.
He informed that under the Mother and Child Tracking System, data for nearly 16
million mothers and 11 million children has already been gathered. Secretary
also informed that with 2012 year declared as ‘intensification for
immunization’ efforts for strengthening immunization system and improving
vaccine coverage are priority.
Thursday, February 2, 2012
Thein Sein for four-day official state visit to Singapore
Myanmar President Thein Sein signed an economic agreement with
Singapore on Monday to receive advice in financial management, monetary
policy and urban development. He also said Burma would eventually like
to create a stock market, according to reports in the local press.“If all goes well, Burma certainly looks forward to being welcomed
from the political wilderness,” said Song Seng Wun a regional economist
with Malaysian bank CIMB, using Burma’s former name.Singapore, a regional financial centre and a favourite hub for global companies, is often seen as a model by its neighbours.
Burma is advancing with fast pace to transform its financial system in a range of areas, including economic planning, central banking, trade facilitation and legal reforms, according to a statement issued on Monday by Singapore’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Thein Sein wrapped up a four-day official state visit to the country on Wednesday. Thein Sein is in Singapore to tap the financial centre's expertise as the country emerges from political and economic isolation, analysts said.
Thein Sein met with Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong and witnessed the signing of a memorandum of understanding on Monday under which Singapore will provide training for reforms in the legal, banking and financial sectors.
The pact also calls on Singapore to share its best practices in trade, tourism and urban planning.
President Thein Sein visit concluded with an agreement for technical assistance and training in a number of key areas including finance, investment law and trade facilitation.Sein reaching out to Singapore brings into the spotlight an economic dimension to the ongoing political reform.
Businesses from many countries have been eager to explore investments in Myanmar. Considered the last large and untapped market in Asia, many sectors of the economy have been underdeveloped or else dominated by Chinese firms.ASEAN) - the regional group to which Myanmar belongs - wants to be supportive and so does Singapore, as a major hub for the region. This goes beyond the politics of having Myanmar assume the group's chairmanship in 2014.
ASEAN's plan for a more integrated economic community, targeted for 2015, can also gain.
Much, however, depends on whether sanctions put in place by the West for more than two decades are lifted. The European Union has already begun to unwind its sanctions. In Washington, a complex legal process is gaining bi-partisan support.
There is cause for optimism, but is Myanmar ready for business and investment? Can the country follow up on its current political reform with parallel reforms to the economy and boost the country's development?
A recent publication by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) predicts the economy will grow at a rate of some 5.5 per cent for 2012. Such projections - in line with neighbouring Indochinese economies - are significant given the weak global outlook. But there is potential for greater, sustained growth.
Consider the country's ample natural resources of oil and gas, as well as forestry products and minerals. Factor in a strategic location that can link China, India and South-east Asia. Add also that Myanmar has a sizeable population of some 54 million, many of whom are of working age and eager for jobs. The economy, among the region's poorest at present, has the potential to grow.
There are, of course, concerns, many of which are typical of frontier economies - like the need for infrastructure and concerns about corruption and power shifts during this political change. But Myanmar also faces special challenges.
One key issue - as pointed out by the IMF - are exchange controls and currency stability. Officially, US$1 (S$1.26) is exchanged for just six Myanmar kyats. But in the widespread black market, the rate currently hovers around 750 kyats and has been as high in recent years as 1,250 kyats. Only with astute financial management can the country hope to liberalise its currency while maintaining macro-economic stability.
Experts are in opinion ,Another issue to watch will be the central government's effort to settle decades of fighting with different ethnic groups. The recent ceasefire deal with the Karen is a prime example. The Karen have been active in the Dawei industrial zone in the south of the country and this is now undergoing a major overhaul worth US$50 billion as a cornerstone of the government's revitalisation plan.
When economic moves ahead, essentially one go beyond for development is to be attained in tandem with political reform, the government must give attention to skill education, training,providing basic needs health,dwelling and education.
Myanmar requires Singapore's expertise in finance, law and providing public services can help Myanmar kick-start holistic development. The agreement was in many ways to be expected, given that the countries have long-standing ties in trade, training programmes for public officials.Economic reform is merging an issue and the agreement with Singapore is an early step on this path. Advocates for human rights and democracy will continue to watch developments in Myanmar but expect that businesses too will increasingly be part of the equation for change.
Burma, once it brings its financial system and laws up to international standards, has a rapid growth potential, observers say, but for now establishing more democratic reforms, more reliable business regulations, a stable foreign exchange system, and the rule of law are pre-conditions to serious business investments by international companies, which nevertheless are lining up to enter the country when conditions improve.
International Monetary Fund said on Jan. 25. that Burma’s economy may grow 5.5 percent in the 2011-2012 fiscal year and 6 percent in 2012-2013 on commodity exports and higher investment.
Singapore and Southeast Asian Nations gave a clarion a call this month for Western nations to lift sanctions against the former military dictatorship. Singapore was Burma’s third-largest trading partner in 2010 behind Thailand and China, said Voice of America, quoting statistics compiled by the European Union. Some members of the EU are calling for a removal of some sanctions after Burma’s April 1 by-election, provided it is free and fair.
Thein Sein, in a series of meetings with Western foreign ministers and high-level officials, has been pushing for the removal of Western sanctions. During the past year, he has granted amnesty to hundreds of political prisoners to achieve national reconciliation and repeated statements that achieving peace with ethnic armed groups is now his highest priority.
Hla Maung Shwe, vice president of the Myanmar Chamber of Commerce and Industry, said in a Jan. 27 interview in Hong Kong the end of sanctions would “have a huge impact on our economy.
New Light of Myanmar said that last year, when a new nominally-civilian government took power and implemented a series of reform gestures, was a “transition period from the old era to the new one”.
“Most international observers were taken aback by the fact that Myanmar [Burma], which had been ruled by an authoritarian Tatmadaw government… has started practising democracy,” said an editorial ahead of Independence Day on 4 January. Tatmadaw is the term for the military.
Burma is advancing with fast pace to transform its financial system in a range of areas, including economic planning, central banking, trade facilitation and legal reforms, according to a statement issued on Monday by Singapore’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Thein Sein wrapped up a four-day official state visit to the country on Wednesday. Thein Sein is in Singapore to tap the financial centre's expertise as the country emerges from political and economic isolation, analysts said.
Thein Sein met with Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong and witnessed the signing of a memorandum of understanding on Monday under which Singapore will provide training for reforms in the legal, banking and financial sectors.
The pact also calls on Singapore to share its best practices in trade, tourism and urban planning.
President Thein Sein visit concluded with an agreement for technical assistance and training in a number of key areas including finance, investment law and trade facilitation.Sein reaching out to Singapore brings into the spotlight an economic dimension to the ongoing political reform.
Businesses from many countries have been eager to explore investments in Myanmar. Considered the last large and untapped market in Asia, many sectors of the economy have been underdeveloped or else dominated by Chinese firms.ASEAN) - the regional group to which Myanmar belongs - wants to be supportive and so does Singapore, as a major hub for the region. This goes beyond the politics of having Myanmar assume the group's chairmanship in 2014.
ASEAN's plan for a more integrated economic community, targeted for 2015, can also gain.
Much, however, depends on whether sanctions put in place by the West for more than two decades are lifted. The European Union has already begun to unwind its sanctions. In Washington, a complex legal process is gaining bi-partisan support.
There is cause for optimism, but is Myanmar ready for business and investment? Can the country follow up on its current political reform with parallel reforms to the economy and boost the country's development?
A recent publication by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) predicts the economy will grow at a rate of some 5.5 per cent for 2012. Such projections - in line with neighbouring Indochinese economies - are significant given the weak global outlook. But there is potential for greater, sustained growth.
Consider the country's ample natural resources of oil and gas, as well as forestry products and minerals. Factor in a strategic location that can link China, India and South-east Asia. Add also that Myanmar has a sizeable population of some 54 million, many of whom are of working age and eager for jobs. The economy, among the region's poorest at present, has the potential to grow.
There are, of course, concerns, many of which are typical of frontier economies - like the need for infrastructure and concerns about corruption and power shifts during this political change. But Myanmar also faces special challenges.
One key issue - as pointed out by the IMF - are exchange controls and currency stability. Officially, US$1 (S$1.26) is exchanged for just six Myanmar kyats. But in the widespread black market, the rate currently hovers around 750 kyats and has been as high in recent years as 1,250 kyats. Only with astute financial management can the country hope to liberalise its currency while maintaining macro-economic stability.
Experts are in opinion ,Another issue to watch will be the central government's effort to settle decades of fighting with different ethnic groups. The recent ceasefire deal with the Karen is a prime example. The Karen have been active in the Dawei industrial zone in the south of the country and this is now undergoing a major overhaul worth US$50 billion as a cornerstone of the government's revitalisation plan.
When economic moves ahead, essentially one go beyond for development is to be attained in tandem with political reform, the government must give attention to skill education, training,providing basic needs health,dwelling and education.
Myanmar requires Singapore's expertise in finance, law and providing public services can help Myanmar kick-start holistic development. The agreement was in many ways to be expected, given that the countries have long-standing ties in trade, training programmes for public officials.Economic reform is merging an issue and the agreement with Singapore is an early step on this path. Advocates for human rights and democracy will continue to watch developments in Myanmar but expect that businesses too will increasingly be part of the equation for change.
Burma, once it brings its financial system and laws up to international standards, has a rapid growth potential, observers say, but for now establishing more democratic reforms, more reliable business regulations, a stable foreign exchange system, and the rule of law are pre-conditions to serious business investments by international companies, which nevertheless are lining up to enter the country when conditions improve.
International Monetary Fund said on Jan. 25. that Burma’s economy may grow 5.5 percent in the 2011-2012 fiscal year and 6 percent in 2012-2013 on commodity exports and higher investment.
Singapore and Southeast Asian Nations gave a clarion a call this month for Western nations to lift sanctions against the former military dictatorship. Singapore was Burma’s third-largest trading partner in 2010 behind Thailand and China, said Voice of America, quoting statistics compiled by the European Union. Some members of the EU are calling for a removal of some sanctions after Burma’s April 1 by-election, provided it is free and fair.
Thein Sein, in a series of meetings with Western foreign ministers and high-level officials, has been pushing for the removal of Western sanctions. During the past year, he has granted amnesty to hundreds of political prisoners to achieve national reconciliation and repeated statements that achieving peace with ethnic armed groups is now his highest priority.
Hla Maung Shwe, vice president of the Myanmar Chamber of Commerce and Industry, said in a Jan. 27 interview in Hong Kong the end of sanctions would “have a huge impact on our economy.
New Light of Myanmar said that last year, when a new nominally-civilian government took power and implemented a series of reform gestures, was a “transition period from the old era to the new one”.
“Most international observers were taken aback by the fact that Myanmar [Burma], which had been ruled by an authoritarian Tatmadaw government… has started practising democracy,” said an editorial ahead of Independence Day on 4 January. Tatmadaw is the term for the military.
Swamy:Collective failure of Cabinet
Nksagar Sagar Media Inc: New Delhi:
Massive irregularities have been been found in the 2G Licensing procedures followed by government of India as per the verdict of Supreme Court of India.Supreme Court has thus asked Licenses given to the corporate viz are 122 licenses stands quashed with conditional grace.
(live-PR.com) - Petitioner of 2 G Scam, Dr Swamy says it is biggest indictment of Government and the failure of the Government of India .It is collective failure of the Cabinet. Government has overlooked the entire procedures.CAG,CVC has warned about it but none of the Minister spoke about it. Chidambaram gets breather and all 122 telecom licenses has been cancelled by Supreme Court in its historical judgment.Kapil Sibal said, SC has not made any pungent remark on the Prime Minister and Home Minister.
Kapil further added that ,”First Come and First Serve,” is per say the theme core of the auction Policy of 2003 of NDA Regime. Narrating Supreme Court judgment he said, Court clarified telecom policy and there is no cause of concern.Apex Court has not indicted any UPA minister but indicted the underlines of Telecom Policy of 2003.The advise of the PM and the then FM has not be been followed by the then telecom Minister. The judgment said the dates of the auction and application of tenders has changes irregularly and court has cognize to this effect. There is an aberration in the policy procedures followed. Kapil Sibal answering the media question said,”What TRAI said we will follow.”
Answering media to question, on 2G Spectrum, When it is collectively responsibility then why the cabinet has not taken any action in this regard? Kapil Sibal said, DOT did not heed to advises given by the concerned authorities.
Massive irregularities have been been found in the 2G Licensing procedures followed by government of India as per the verdict of Supreme Court of India.Supreme Court has thus asked Licenses given to the corporate viz are 122 licenses stands quashed with conditional grace.
(live-PR.com) - Petitioner of 2 G Scam, Dr Swamy says it is biggest indictment of Government and the failure of the Government of India .It is collective failure of the Cabinet. Government has overlooked the entire procedures.CAG,CVC has warned about it but none of the Minister spoke about it. Chidambaram gets breather and all 122 telecom licenses has been cancelled by Supreme Court in its historical judgment.Kapil Sibal said, SC has not made any pungent remark on the Prime Minister and Home Minister.
Kapil further added that ,”First Come and First Serve,” is per say the theme core of the auction Policy of 2003 of NDA Regime. Narrating Supreme Court judgment he said, Court clarified telecom policy and there is no cause of concern.Apex Court has not indicted any UPA minister but indicted the underlines of Telecom Policy of 2003.The advise of the PM and the then FM has not be been followed by the then telecom Minister. The judgment said the dates of the auction and application of tenders has changes irregularly and court has cognize to this effect. There is an aberration in the policy procedures followed. Kapil Sibal answering the media question said,”What TRAI said we will follow.”
Answering media to question, on 2G Spectrum, When it is collectively responsibility then why the cabinet has not taken any action in this regard? Kapil Sibal said, DOT did not heed to advises given by the concerned authorities.
Those, the custodian, of government treasury has given clean path to tread for corrupting it, said BJP leader Arun Jaitley further adds “It was collective decision of cabinet and
therefore the cabinet cannot absolve itself or deprive to its
responsibility.Whenever it was brought to their notice {by autonomous
bodies CAG,CVC} ,the government said it is "Coalition Dharma,"thus the
cabinet is liable for the scam.”
Italy has been invited to participate as Partner Country to the 36th Kolkata International Bookfair 2012, reciprocating India’s participation in 2010 in the Book Fair in Turin , the largest of its kind in Italy which takes place every year in May.
The
Italian participation in the Kolkata Book Fair will not only promote
Italian literature with the participation of some of the most
translated and best known Italian writers such as Dacia Maraini,
Alessandro Baricco, Beppe Severgnini, Valerio Massimo Manfredi but also
authors with a longstanding relation with India and its culture such
as Angela Staude Terzani and Sandra Petrignani. Indian authors who
contribute to promote Italy in India such as Ritu Dalmia or Dileep
Padgaonkar will also participate.
On this ocassion, Embassy of Italy and Istituto Italiano di Cultura are holding the following event
MEET THE AUTHORS
KOLKATA BOOK FAIR – COLLATERAL EVENTS in Delhi
Dacia Maraini 31st January, 6:30
in conversation with Ms. Urvashi Butalia
Valerio Massimo Manfredi Ist February, 6:30 pm
in conversation with Mahmood Farooqui
Beppe Severgnini 2nd February, 6:30 pm
in conversation with Jug Suraiya
Due to unforseen circumstances, Mr. Shekhar Gupta is not able to make it. Mr. Jug Suraiya has kindly consented to hold the conversation with Mr. Beppe Severgnini. Please find the invite and a profile of Mr. Suraiya.
All the above events will take place at 6:30 pm at Multimedia Hall, Istituto Italiano di Cultura
Regards,
Istituto Italiano di Cultura
50-E, Chandragupta Marg,
Chanakyapuri, New Delhi - 110 021
50-E, Chandragupta Marg,
Chanakyapuri, New Delhi - 110 021
“India and ASEAN: Partners for Peace, Progress and Stability”
Towards Economic Integration: Prospects & Challenges
THE DELHI DIALOGUE IV
“India and ASEAN: Partners for Peace, Progress and Stability”
February 14, 2012, Time: 9.30-11.00am, Hotel Taj Palace, New Delhi
The
Delhi Dialogue IV (a Regional Security & Cooperation Dialogue) is
being organized by FICCI in partnership with the Ministry of External
Affairs & Indian Council of World Affairs (ICWA) in support with
Institute of south East Asian Studies (ISEAS), Singapore and SAEA Group
after the resounding success of the earlier three Conferences.
The
theme for the Delhi-Dialogue IV is “India and ASEAN: Partners for
Peace, Progress and Stability” which seeks to underscore India’s
increasing engagement with ASEAN countries and to explore an agenda for
the consolidation of this relationship in the coming years. The Dialogue
is also significant given that India and ASEAN will celebrate two
decades of their institutionalized engagement in 2012.
The
idea of this Annual Conference is to get together policy makers,
businesses, think tanks as well as politicians from India and the ASEAN
countries, under one roof, to discuss the way forward for addressing
various issues of common interest.
Chrysler back in black two years after bankruptcy
Chrysler's
remarkable success at the hands of Italy's Fiat comes after failed
marriages to German's Daimler and private equity group Cerberus and
years of painful restructuring.
Chrysler's
full year net income rose to USD 183 million from a USD 652 million
loss in 2010, thanks to fourth quarter earnings of USD 225 million.
Chrysler
forecast that net income would jump to around USD 1.5 billion in 2012
as revenues rise to USD 65 billion from USD 55 billion in 2011 and USD
42 billion in 2010.
"The
house is in good order. We are proud of the work we've done," said
Sergio Marchionne, chairman and chief executive of Chrysler and Fiat.
SC to pronounce verdict on plea for probe against Chidambaram
The judgements will be pronounced by a bench comprising justices G S Singhvi and A K Ganguly which had reserved its verdict on the plea for probe against Chidambaram and for cancellation of licences of spectrum on October 10 and March 17 respectively last year.
The unanimous verdicts on both the petitions would be pronounced by Justice Singhvi.
Since Justice Ganguly is retiring on Thursday, he will be sitting in a bench headed by Chief Justice of India S H Kapadia.
The
petitions on both the issues were filed by NGO Centre for Public
Interest Litigation (CPIL) and Janata Party chief Subramanian Swamy.
The
role of Chidambaram in the 2G scam was raised in the Supreme Court by
the petitioners who had pointed out that there was evidence on record
showing that the decision regarding pricing of spectrum was taken
jointly by him and Raja.
A
Finance Ministry note to the PMO signed by Pranab Mukherjee was also
taken on record by the apex court in which it was stated that the scam
could have been averted had Chidambram suggested the policy of auction
instead of first-come-first-served policy on allocation of spectrum.
The
Centre and CBI had vehemently opposed any probe against Chidambram who
was the Finance Minister at the time of allotment of spectrum in 2008.
They had maintained that Chidambaram was not in direct communication
with the then Telecom Minister A Raja in determining the price of the
radio waves.
However,
Swamy and the Centre for Public Interest Litigation (CPIL) had refuted
the claims of CBI and the Centre that Chidambaram was not in the picture
till January, 10, 2008, when the Department of Telecommunication (DoT)
headed by Raja issued 122 Letters of Intent (LoIs) to telecom companies
without following the policy of auction.
Swamy
and CPIL's counsel Prashant Bhushan had contended Chidambaram was
"consistently" informed of what was going on and "till November 30,
2007, Chidambaram was apprised of what Raja was upto".
Swamy
and Bhushan said the Finance Ministry officials were for allocation of
spectrum through auction but they were overruled by Chidambaram. Swamy
said there there were documents to show that Raja and Chidambaram met
four times on the issue and had a meeting of minds in the commission of
the offences.
7 Habits of Unsuccessful CEOs
By
SiliconIndia,Wednesday, 01 February 2012, 17:28 IST
Bangalore: "Why Smart Executives Fail" was a book published by Sydney Finkelstein, the Steven Roth Professor of Management at the Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth College. The book spoke about how big companies turned out to be complete failures due to the habits of their seniors or executives. These habits are registered in some of the leading executives of these days which can be warning signs for them. Listed below are the habits that Finkelstein described in a 2004 article:
I and My Companies Rule the World
This is the most sinister habit, as it appears very enviable. But don't you think a company should not aim at dominating the market rather shape the future of its market? The failed leaders fail to realize that they are at the mercy of change in circumstances. They feel they control events and underestimate the changing trends in the market. The illusion of personal supremacy is what traps CEOs. They felt that they have all the control over the company and as far as others in the company, they are just to execute their personal vision for the company. Samsung's CEO Kun-Hee Lee was successful with electronics which made him feel he could equally do well in automobiles and he invested $5 million on the oversaturated market. He just entered the auto business because he loved cars, there was no business case. The warning sign here is lack of respect.
Personal Interest and Corporation's Interest Becomes One
This habit might look harmless and beneficial. A company always demands for a dedicated and committed leader, with their interests associated with the company. But if we have a deeper look at the failed executives, we will see that, rather than considering their company as enterprise and nurturing it, these executives treated them as an extended part of themselves. CEOs with such mentality carry out their personal ambitions by using their companies. Most of these CEOs use company funds for personal use, which pushes them towards the slippery grounds. CEOs who have impressive track and feel that the company has made huge profits with him are so even if they likely to make expensive expenditures it will always appear less by comparison. Dennis Kozlowski of Tyco was majorly influenced by this logic. His pride in his company and his pride in his own profligacy seem to have reinforced each other. Being the CEO in a company is almost a king in your realm, which can turn very dangerous with time.
I Know it All
A dynamic leader is known for making dozen decisions at his finger tips, dealing with crises, and we admire such a leader. But in reality it's a fraud. Leaders who are perpetually decisive are inclined towards settling issues so quickly that they have no chance to take hold of consequences. They are so arrogant that they are never open to new ideas and they have this feeling that they know it all. Leaders who need to have all the answers shut out other points of view. When your company or organization is run by someone like this, you better hope the answers he comes up with are going to be the right ones.
If You Don't Follow Me, You are Eliminated
CEOs have this feeling that that all are bound to follow their vision and it is the job of everyone to buy what he says. Those who don't tally with the vision will are only given two options: either go with the plan or leave the company. This approach is unnecessary and destructive. It's not logical for a CEO to expect everyone to agree with his views. As the CEO arises, they cut off their chances to see and correct their problems. Many executives leave as soon as they are on board, once they realize their CEO is not in their support. Ultimately, these CEOs had everyone on their staff completely behind them, they are heading towards disaster. And he has no one to warn him.
Obsession for the Company Image
High profile CEOs are always in public eye. Amid all this public frenzy leaders become low and unproductive as they are constantly tring to accomplishing things than achieveing things. When CEOs are obsessed with their image they have little time for operational details. The top priority for a CEO is company's image. They even take the jeopardy of using financial-reporting practices to promote that image. They treat their financial accounts as a control tool, rather than treating them as a public-relations tool.
Underestimate Obstacle
When CEOs turn out to be so charmed of their vision, they frequently overlook or underestimate the difficulty of actually getting there. When the obstacles turn out as pain they casually wave them sideways which turns more bothersome than they predict. These CEO have a custom of dropping full-steam into the void. Some CEOs are obsessed to be correct all the time, because they feel making a mistake can pull the "CEO Chair" behind. If CEO makes fallible decisions they will receive criticism. These unrealistic expectations make them push too hard.
Stubborn About Past Practices
Some CEO is always adamant to follow the tried and used methods, which pushes the company into devastation. What they desire as their core strength, actually makes them clinging to a fixed business model. Inability to make innovations results in failure. CEOs generally fall prey to this habit. They feel the one thing they are most known for will get all the work done for them every time. Once they become the CEO of a company they allow their defining moment to identify the company as well, not being bothered how impractical it has become.
Businesses at Asia’s biggest IT mecca to fight it out
Businesses at Asia’s biggest IT mecca to fight it out
Assert right to Safer,
Cleaner and Regulated Nehru Place
New Delhi February 1, 2012
Fed up by the civic apathy
to offering a clean, safe and regulated environment to conduct business, nearly
2000 shops, retailers and offices shut down Asia’s biggest IT mecca, Nehru
Place, today.
A bustling shopping market
in south Delhi
wore a deserted look as the Presidents of 5, Nehru Place associations jointly asserted
their right to a Safer, Cleaner and Regulated work environment.
Led by Nehru Place
Improvement and Welfare Association (NIWA) President Anil K Sehgal, the
presidents of the four associations dealing with Export Fabrics, Computer
Hardware, Peripherals and Media distribution made fervent pleas to the civic
and administrative authorities to rise and help restore a Safer, Cleaner and
Regulated work environment.
“We shall continue to ask
for the pride of place that Nehru Place had come to deserve as a commercial hub
adding Rs. 1000 crore annually to the government revenues,” asserted Mr. Sehgal.
The working group of the ‘Nehru Place Bachao’ will continue to bring up issues with
various bodies till they are completely resolved both in letter and spirit.
“Business and trading
community from city’s busiest commercial hub, Nehru Place will continue its Nehru Place
Bachao’ campaign kicked off as
a peaceful protest here today”, the statement added.
The core committee decided
to support move by the government to check unregulated hawking so as to quickly
get off the ‘list of 30 most
notorious cities in the world’ as
none of its members were engaged in any such activity.
“While we respect the right
of every citizen to earn a living, they must do so within the legal framework”,
added the joint statement issued at the end of the peaceful protest attended by
several thousand people.
Nehru Place, Asia’s biggest
computer hardware and peripherals distribution hub,
That has of late been facing
deteriorating civic amenities led the Core committee to seek the support of the
Lt. Governor of Delhi to ameliorate pathetic conditions being faced by Nehru
Place occupants.
Nehru Place, designed to be one of the modern complexes by Delhi
Development Authority (DDA) in 1970s, has over the years regressed into one of
the filthiest markets in the national capital, especially during rains.
Nearly 12,500 people engaged
in 1283 businesses and offices in Nehru
Place who have signed a plea to the Lt. Governor
of Delhi to
save this burgeoning business hub, stayed away from work and participated in
the peaceful protest.
The core committee of 5
associations that addressed several thousand occupants under‘ Nehru Place Bachao’ campaign sought authorities to provide
and improve facilities due to the genuine occupants of Nehru Place shops and offices in keeping
with the changing times.
The Core Group—comprising
Anil K Sehgal, President,Nehru Place Improvement & Welfare Association,
NIWA; Mahinder Aggarwal, President, All Delhi Computer Traders Association
(ADCTA), HR Sahni, President, Export Fabric Suppliers Association (EFSA);
Puneet Singhal, President, Computer Media Dealers’ Association (CMDA) and R.K.
Malhotra, President, Progressive Channels Association of Information Technology
(PCAIT)-- agreed to maintain pressure on the authorities in the coming weeks
and months.
The CFO Leadership Summit takes a 360-degree view of some of the most innovative ways U.S. companies are transforming themselves into resilient enterprises, positioning themselves to withstand an array of risks—from rising energy and commodity prices to global economic instability—and not only survive, but thrive in today’s environment. The summit will explore the latest trends in risk and resource management and provide you with valuable insight into how to implement cutting-edge best practices that will help your organization succeed in a volatile global marketplace. Learn how finance can help companies not only protect themselves from risk, but also identify opportunities in today’s ever-changing landscape.
Attend this dynamic, newly updated CFO event to gain a big-picture view of the changes happening in the global landscape as well as tactics for addressing them, and make meaningful connections with fellow finance executives and experts who can share insights into how they are helping their companies become more resilient, balancing the risks and opportunities in business today.
Attend this unique event and you’ll hear:
- Powerful insights from industry visionaries on the changing financial landscape
- In-depth analysis of key issues that affect how you do your job
- Insightful, practical leadership advice from provocative panels and roundtable discussions
- Lessons from great brands that succeed by reinvention and reinvigoration
- Tactics for exceeding expectations from customers who want sustainable products
- Relevant solutions from leading vendors on the exhibit floor
- Winning strategies being implemented by your peers
- Earn up to 31 CPE credits
Draft National Water Policy 2012
Not the Farmers, Not the Environment
Draft National Policy 2012 seems to help only vested interests
National Water Policies are extremely important legal and institutional tools as they reflect the basic intent and direction that the government is planning to take regarding water resources. To ensure that this is a direction acceptable and beneficial to all, open public consultations need to be the backbones of such policies. Thus looking at the immense importance of water to society & environment it is extremely important to have consultations on the recently published Draft 2012 National Water Policy1, especially at the grassroots levels right upto the gram sabhas so that the ground concerns get reflected in the policy. Having limited participation of communities in the process threatens to make the exercise almost entirely undemocratic and is likely to be hijacked by the vested interests. Though it has been stated that consultations about the Policy have been held2, these are far from adequate and have not be publicised enough to ensure wide participation. Most of these were not open consultations, but consisted of invited delegates. This cannot be called as an open, inclusive process. Four regional consultations were organised with Panchayati Raj representatives and it will be too ambitious to assume that four such meetings in cities can reflect rural concerns entirely. As it is, many of the important points raised in the Panchayati Raj institutions consultations do not find a mention in the Draft Policy.
The exercise of reformulating the NWP was taken up also in the context of Climate change, as mentioned in the National Action Plan for Climate Change and also the National Water Mission, and that makes it all the more important those vulnerable sections (tribals, rainfed farmers, small and marginal farmers, coastal communities, hill communities, fisherfolks, women and rural populations, the populations in the north east and western ghats) are all consulted in the process, which does not seem to be the case with the current draft.
The draft National Policy 2012 differs greatly from its1987 and 2002 predecessors in the direction it seems to be taking as well as some of its basic premises. Hence, the significance of a transparent consultation process before proceeding forward becomes even more crucial.
Some of the major areas of concern from the draft of the National Policy include:
1 http://mowr.gov.in/writereaddata/linkimages/DraftNWP2012_English9353289094.pdf and http://mowr.gov.in/writereaddata/linkimages/DraftNWP2012_Hindi182295781.pdf and their PR at: http://pib.nic.in/newsite/erelease.aspx?relid=79981
2 http://wrmin.nic.in/index1.asp?linkid=201&langid=1
Unlike the previous policies, this policy does not spell out the clear priorities of water allocation. It accords first stated priority to basic livelihood needs and ecosystem needs. This can be considered as a welcome step only if all the specificities about water allocation for livelihoods and ecosystem needs are worked out, discussed and accepted along with the necessary legal and institutional back up. In the absence of any of these, just a statement that “After meeting the minimum quantity of water required for survival of human beings and ecosystem, water will be treated as an economic good” may end up making water ONLY an economic good. The National Policy of 2002 had also stated that minimum flows will be maintained in rivers, but in the absence of any further direction, nothing happened on this front for the last 10 years anywhere in the country, and the state of Indian rivers have only worsened in the period. When the South African Water Act was passed in 1997, based on the White Paper on South African Water and Sanitation Policy, 1994, the policy took a detailed look at defining water for basic human needs, its quality, quantity, access, distance, etc, as well as various issues related to water and environment. It was only with this background that South Africa could take the revolutionary step of securing water for basic human needs and ecological reserves first. It went through a rigorous, extensive process of consultations with the communities and other stakeholders (which still continues) to actually calculate the reserve, implement it and monitor it.
When India’s Draft NWP 2012 mentions that ‘Access to safe and clean drinking water and sanitation should be regarded as a right to life essential to the full enjoyment of life and all other human rights’, this statement needs to be strongly qualified in the context of exhausting all local options, demand side management measures and ensuring maximum reuse and recycle. In the absence of this, large dams and infrastructure projects will continue to be planned and justified for wasteful needs of large cities like Mumbai and Delhi as is happening now, without considering the carrying capacity and sustainability of ecosystems involved.
The sub section on Adaptation to Climate change and the statement that special attention will be given towards mitigation at micro level by enhancing the capabilities of community to adopt climate resilient technological options is welcome. However, the crucial lesson which is being learnt the world over, of how to make the huge existing water infrastructure (which is currently causing more problems in face of unpredictable climate change) more responsive and adaptable to climate change is not addressed here. Also the need for sustainable agricultural practices like increasing soil’s capacity to retain moisture by increasing soil carbon content, System of Rice Intensification (SRI), organic farming, etc as coping measures for climate change also do not find a mention. The world over, ecological coping strategies like flood forecasting, flood preparedness, flood regulation zones, riparian belts, mangrove protection, biological bank stabilization methods etc., are used as coping and adaptation measures . These biological, low impact and low investment measures do not find a mention on our draft policy, but infrastructure-heavy interventions like embankments and dams have been pushed again.
Though the policy does not say a word about increasing the soil moisture content, which actually should be the first objective of all irrigation strategies, it supports and even encourages inter basin
water transfers from so called ‘open basins’ to ‘closed basins’. This is highly inappropriate. Firstly we need to assess the exhaust the potential of sustainable options like watershed development, local water harvesting systems, rooftop and other rainwater harvesting, local ground water recharge, demand side management, including water saving methods like SRI, SSI (Sustainable Sugar Initiative), water saving cropping patterns, and also avoid non essential water intensive activities, recycling by water intensive industries and so on. In the absence of such concerted efforts in any basin of the country, and in the face of the high inefficiency, social and ecological impacts of large infrastructure projects, such encouragement to inter basin transfers is unviable and unacceptable.
The section on project planning and implementation begins, as expected directly with large multipurpose infrastructure projects, without even mentioning the appropriateness of subsidiarity principle. After making a number of oft-repeated, bland statements about participation, etc, it goes on to make a shocking statement that all ‘All water resources projects, including hydro power projects, should be planned to the extent feasible as multi-purpose projects with provision of storage’. This is a dangerous statement to make. Giving privileged position to such mega storages compared to other storage options (e.g. increasing soil capacity to retain moisture, local storages, underground storages) and optimum use of existing storage capacities is uncalled for. On the other hand, there is need for an assessment of the benefits from existing projects to ensure how they can be optimised. There is a huge potential which should be acknowledged and prioritised. Secondly, there is need for basin wide carrying capacity, cumulative impact assessment studies in each basin in a credible independent way to ensure that unviable capacities and storages are not added.
The section on Institutional Arrangements also has some unpleasant surprises. It begins with the statement that Water Resources Regulatory Authorities (WRRA) are a must in each state. WRRA was first established in Maharashtra in 2005 through the MWRRA Act. The centralised, top down bureaucratic authority with no space for community representatives has been ineffective in achieving any worthwhile objective or making water resources management pro poor or pro environment or stopping inter sector water allocation. The act has now been amended by an ordinance which gives rights of water allocation to the cabinet, which chose to change water allocation from farmers on verge of suicides in Vidarbha to thermal power plants. So what is the basis on which WRRA are being pushed for in the National Water Policy, apart from the fact that it is pushed by the World Bank?
A most shocking statement in the Policy is the assertion that “The “Service Provider” role of the state has to be gradually reduced and shifted to regulation and control of services. The water related services should be transferred to community and / OR private sector ...” “Public Private Partnership” model under the general superintendence of the State or the stakeholders. This seems to be a blanket go ahead for water privatisation, which has been proved to be anti people, anti poor, pro private water utilities and hence unacceptable. Privatisation has not succeeded anywhere and is not likely to succeed in any case in India, and will only work towards worsening the water services scene, particularly for the poor, but actually for everyone. Particularly when we have no credible
mechanisms to ensure transparent, accountable water resources management, nor do we have laws to ensure legally enforceable right to water and democratic norms.
Another major problem is the sketchy mention of groundwater and very little concerted attention given to the issue. As is clear to everyone from the mounting dependence on groundwater in every water sub sector in India, groundwater is the real water life line of India, be it the urban or the rural sector, agriculture or industries, and it was expected that the policy will state the acute problems faced by the sector and put forth concrete steps of overcoming these and conserving the resource, which has not happened.
The attention given in the Draft NWP 2012 to information sharing, climate change, priority to basic human needs and ecosystems are welcome, but these may remain at superficial lip service level without clearly defined norms and credible mechanisms to achieve these objectives.
On the whole, the anti farmer, pro private company, anti poor stance of the current draft is disappointing and it seems the water resources establishment has refused to learn lessons from the past. There has been only a notional attempt at a democratic process in the formulation of the new draft policy and it seems an opportunity that comes once in a generation may be lost if we hurry too much to proceed without open, publicised consultations right down to gram sabha level. We urge the water resources establishment, including the Union Ministry of Water Resources, Central Water Commission and the Planning Commission to reinstate a credible participatory, democratic process for formulating new National Water Policy in the changing climate, keeping societal and ecosystemic sustainability and equity in mind. A mere 29 days period for comments from the date of publication, that too when the draft policy is put up only on the website, seems too less for ground concerns to reach the administration. 3
Himanshu Thakkar (ht.sandrp@gmail.com),
Parineeta Dandekar (parineeta.dandekar@gmail.com)
1 February 2012
www.sandrp.in
www.facebook.com/sandrp.in
3 Last date for sending
Not the Farmers, Not the Environment
Draft National Policy 2012 seems to help only vested interests
National Water Policies are extremely important legal and institutional tools as they reflect the basic intent and direction that the government is planning to take regarding water resources. To ensure that this is a direction acceptable and beneficial to all, open public consultations need to be the backbones of such policies. Thus looking at the immense importance of water to society & environment it is extremely important to have consultations on the recently published Draft 2012 National Water Policy1, especially at the grassroots levels right upto the gram sabhas so that the ground concerns get reflected in the policy. Having limited participation of communities in the process threatens to make the exercise almost entirely undemocratic and is likely to be hijacked by the vested interests. Though it has been stated that consultations about the Policy have been held2, these are far from adequate and have not be publicised enough to ensure wide participation. Most of these were not open consultations, but consisted of invited delegates. This cannot be called as an open, inclusive process. Four regional consultations were organised with Panchayati Raj representatives and it will be too ambitious to assume that four such meetings in cities can reflect rural concerns entirely. As it is, many of the important points raised in the Panchayati Raj institutions consultations do not find a mention in the Draft Policy.
The exercise of reformulating the NWP was taken up also in the context of Climate change, as mentioned in the National Action Plan for Climate Change and also the National Water Mission, and that makes it all the more important those vulnerable sections (tribals, rainfed farmers, small and marginal farmers, coastal communities, hill communities, fisherfolks, women and rural populations, the populations in the north east and western ghats) are all consulted in the process, which does not seem to be the case with the current draft.
The draft National Policy 2012 differs greatly from its1987 and 2002 predecessors in the direction it seems to be taking as well as some of its basic premises. Hence, the significance of a transparent consultation process before proceeding forward becomes even more crucial.
Some of the major areas of concern from the draft of the National Policy include:
1 http://mowr.gov.in/writereaddata/linkimages/DraftNWP2012_English9353289094.pdf and http://mowr.gov.in/writereaddata/linkimages/DraftNWP2012_Hindi182295781.pdf and their PR at: http://pib.nic.in/newsite/erelease.aspx?relid=79981
2 http://wrmin.nic.in/index1.asp?linkid=201&langid=1
Unlike the previous policies, this policy does not spell out the clear priorities of water allocation. It accords first stated priority to basic livelihood needs and ecosystem needs. This can be considered as a welcome step only if all the specificities about water allocation for livelihoods and ecosystem needs are worked out, discussed and accepted along with the necessary legal and institutional back up. In the absence of any of these, just a statement that “After meeting the minimum quantity of water required for survival of human beings and ecosystem, water will be treated as an economic good” may end up making water ONLY an economic good. The National Policy of 2002 had also stated that minimum flows will be maintained in rivers, but in the absence of any further direction, nothing happened on this front for the last 10 years anywhere in the country, and the state of Indian rivers have only worsened in the period. When the South African Water Act was passed in 1997, based on the White Paper on South African Water and Sanitation Policy, 1994, the policy took a detailed look at defining water for basic human needs, its quality, quantity, access, distance, etc, as well as various issues related to water and environment. It was only with this background that South Africa could take the revolutionary step of securing water for basic human needs and ecological reserves first. It went through a rigorous, extensive process of consultations with the communities and other stakeholders (which still continues) to actually calculate the reserve, implement it and monitor it.
When India’s Draft NWP 2012 mentions that ‘Access to safe and clean drinking water and sanitation should be regarded as a right to life essential to the full enjoyment of life and all other human rights’, this statement needs to be strongly qualified in the context of exhausting all local options, demand side management measures and ensuring maximum reuse and recycle. In the absence of this, large dams and infrastructure projects will continue to be planned and justified for wasteful needs of large cities like Mumbai and Delhi as is happening now, without considering the carrying capacity and sustainability of ecosystems involved.
The sub section on Adaptation to Climate change and the statement that special attention will be given towards mitigation at micro level by enhancing the capabilities of community to adopt climate resilient technological options is welcome. However, the crucial lesson which is being learnt the world over, of how to make the huge existing water infrastructure (which is currently causing more problems in face of unpredictable climate change) more responsive and adaptable to climate change is not addressed here. Also the need for sustainable agricultural practices like increasing soil’s capacity to retain moisture by increasing soil carbon content, System of Rice Intensification (SRI), organic farming, etc as coping measures for climate change also do not find a mention. The world over, ecological coping strategies like flood forecasting, flood preparedness, flood regulation zones, riparian belts, mangrove protection, biological bank stabilization methods etc., are used as coping and adaptation measures . These biological, low impact and low investment measures do not find a mention on our draft policy, but infrastructure-heavy interventions like embankments and dams have been pushed again.
Though the policy does not say a word about increasing the soil moisture content, which actually should be the first objective of all irrigation strategies, it supports and even encourages inter basin
water transfers from so called ‘open basins’ to ‘closed basins’. This is highly inappropriate. Firstly we need to assess the exhaust the potential of sustainable options like watershed development, local water harvesting systems, rooftop and other rainwater harvesting, local ground water recharge, demand side management, including water saving methods like SRI, SSI (Sustainable Sugar Initiative), water saving cropping patterns, and also avoid non essential water intensive activities, recycling by water intensive industries and so on. In the absence of such concerted efforts in any basin of the country, and in the face of the high inefficiency, social and ecological impacts of large infrastructure projects, such encouragement to inter basin transfers is unviable and unacceptable.
The section on project planning and implementation begins, as expected directly with large multipurpose infrastructure projects, without even mentioning the appropriateness of subsidiarity principle. After making a number of oft-repeated, bland statements about participation, etc, it goes on to make a shocking statement that all ‘All water resources projects, including hydro power projects, should be planned to the extent feasible as multi-purpose projects with provision of storage’. This is a dangerous statement to make. Giving privileged position to such mega storages compared to other storage options (e.g. increasing soil capacity to retain moisture, local storages, underground storages) and optimum use of existing storage capacities is uncalled for. On the other hand, there is need for an assessment of the benefits from existing projects to ensure how they can be optimised. There is a huge potential which should be acknowledged and prioritised. Secondly, there is need for basin wide carrying capacity, cumulative impact assessment studies in each basin in a credible independent way to ensure that unviable capacities and storages are not added.
The section on Institutional Arrangements also has some unpleasant surprises. It begins with the statement that Water Resources Regulatory Authorities (WRRA) are a must in each state. WRRA was first established in Maharashtra in 2005 through the MWRRA Act. The centralised, top down bureaucratic authority with no space for community representatives has been ineffective in achieving any worthwhile objective or making water resources management pro poor or pro environment or stopping inter sector water allocation. The act has now been amended by an ordinance which gives rights of water allocation to the cabinet, which chose to change water allocation from farmers on verge of suicides in Vidarbha to thermal power plants. So what is the basis on which WRRA are being pushed for in the National Water Policy, apart from the fact that it is pushed by the World Bank?
A most shocking statement in the Policy is the assertion that “The “Service Provider” role of the state has to be gradually reduced and shifted to regulation and control of services. The water related services should be transferred to community and / OR private sector ...” “Public Private Partnership” model under the general superintendence of the State or the stakeholders. This seems to be a blanket go ahead for water privatisation, which has been proved to be anti people, anti poor, pro private water utilities and hence unacceptable. Privatisation has not succeeded anywhere and is not likely to succeed in any case in India, and will only work towards worsening the water services scene, particularly for the poor, but actually for everyone. Particularly when we have no credible
mechanisms to ensure transparent, accountable water resources management, nor do we have laws to ensure legally enforceable right to water and democratic norms.
Another major problem is the sketchy mention of groundwater and very little concerted attention given to the issue. As is clear to everyone from the mounting dependence on groundwater in every water sub sector in India, groundwater is the real water life line of India, be it the urban or the rural sector, agriculture or industries, and it was expected that the policy will state the acute problems faced by the sector and put forth concrete steps of overcoming these and conserving the resource, which has not happened.
The attention given in the Draft NWP 2012 to information sharing, climate change, priority to basic human needs and ecosystems are welcome, but these may remain at superficial lip service level without clearly defined norms and credible mechanisms to achieve these objectives.
On the whole, the anti farmer, pro private company, anti poor stance of the current draft is disappointing and it seems the water resources establishment has refused to learn lessons from the past. There has been only a notional attempt at a democratic process in the formulation of the new draft policy and it seems an opportunity that comes once in a generation may be lost if we hurry too much to proceed without open, publicised consultations right down to gram sabha level. We urge the water resources establishment, including the Union Ministry of Water Resources, Central Water Commission and the Planning Commission to reinstate a credible participatory, democratic process for formulating new National Water Policy in the changing climate, keeping societal and ecosystemic sustainability and equity in mind. A mere 29 days period for comments from the date of publication, that too when the draft policy is put up only on the website, seems too less for ground concerns to reach the administration. 3
Himanshu Thakkar (ht.sandrp@gmail.com),
Parineeta Dandekar (parineeta.dandekar@gmail.com)
1 February 2012
www.sandrp.in
www.facebook.com/sandrp.in
3 Last date for sending
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
NASA : Search for Alien Life on Saturn’s Moon On Thursday NASA announced a mission to land a car-sized robot quadcopter on S...
-
GOVERNMENT TO REVIVE NORTH KOEL IRRIGATION PROJECT Posted on April 8, 2017 Centre has decided to revive the North Koel Irrigation pr...
-
NASA : Search for Alien Life on Saturn’s Moon On Thursday NASA announced a mission to land a car-sized robot quadcopter on S...
-
SAB TV promises a Magical Comedy with Baal Veer ~Starting 8 th October every Mon-Friday at 8pm~ New Delhi,September 27 th...
