February 5, 2012
U.N. envoy Tomas Ojea Quintana speaks to the press at Rangoon International airport on Sunday, February 5.United Nations Human Rights Envoy Tomas Ojea Quintana briefing media said on Sunday
that his six-day Myanmar mission witnessed positive impact in the
country. He further added, serious challenges remain and be addressed.
,"I would like to express my appreciation to the Government of Myanmar for
its invitation and hospitality, and for the cooperation and flexibility
shown during my visit."
Quintana said Myanmar government told that a new draft media law would abolish censorship
and provides some guarantees for the freedom of opinion and expression. I was informed that the process of drafting a
revised Prisons Act, a new media law – the Printing Press and
Publications Law, and a new social security law, among others, were
currently underway.
During the mission, I met with the
Minister of Home Affairs, the Minister of Defence, the Minister of
Border Affairs, the Attorney-General, the Chief Justice of the Supreme
Court, the Union Election Commission, the Deputy Minister of Foreign
Affairs, the Deputy Minister of Information, the Deputy Minister of
Education, the Deputy Minister of Labour, as well as the Speaker and
several members of the Pyi Thu Hluttaw. During my meetings in Nay Pyi
Taw, I also met with some of the Presidential Advisors and
representatives of the Ministry of Social Welfare, Relief and
Resettlement, as well as with members of the various Government and
Parliamentary peacemaking groups, including the Minister of Rail
Transportation.
In Yangon, I had another fruitful exchange of
views with Daw Aung San Suu Kyi. I met with members of the
recently-established National Human Rights Commission and discussed a
range of human rights issues. Additionally, I met with three prisoners
of conscience in Insein Prison, as well as with released prisoners of
conscience, including members of the 88 Generation Students Group, some
of whom I had previously addressed in my reports or had visited in
prison. Also in Yangon, I met with representatives of civil society
organizations and ethnic parties, as well as members of the United
Nations Country Team. I thank the Resident Coordinator and the Country
Team for the support provided to me during my mission. I also travelled
to Kayin and Mon States where I met with the respective Chief Ministers
and representatives of state government, as well as ethnic parties in
state parliaments. At the conclusion of my mission, I briefed the
diplomatic community.
Since my last visit in August 2011, there
has been a continuing wave of reforms in Myanmar, the speed and breadth
of which has surprised many international observers and many in the
country. The impact of these reforms on the country and on its people
is immediately perceptible. During my mission, Parliament was meeting
in its third regular session and was discussing a number of important
issues, including, for the first time, the country’s budget. Legislative
reforms were underway, including a new draft media law which I was told
would abolish censorship and provide some guarantees for the freedom of
opinion and expression. Campaigning for the by-elections scheduled on 1
April had begun in earnest and Daw Aung San Suu Kyi’s activities and
statements were covered in the national media. An initial agreement was
reached with another armed ethnic group and negotiations continued with
others. It was therefore important to assess the human rights situation
in light of these developments and at this key moment in Myanmar’s
history. My report containing my assessment will be presented to the
Human Rights Council in March 2012.
Of great importance is the
release of many prisoners of conscience, including a significant number
in January this year, as well as many prominent figures over the past
few months. I welcomed their release in all my meetings and commended
the Government for taking this bold step. I stressed that they, and all
people of Myanmar, should be allowed to play an active role in political
and public life. In my meeting with released prisoners of conscience, I
received a clear signal of their intention to engage constructively in
the political process and their commitment to further democratic
transition. Our discussion also addressed ongoing human rights concerns,
including continuing limitations on the freedoms of association and
assembly, and of opinion and expression, the continuing conflict in
ethnic border areas, particularly in Kachin State, and the need to
address longstanding social and economic development challenges. I am,
however, concerned by information received that some of those released
were being monitored or followed. I therefore urge that any restrictions
on their exercise and full enjoyment of human rights should immediately
be removed.
I also met with three prisoners of conscience at
Insein Prison, one of whom I had previously met during my mission last
year. While I was informed that prison conditions had generally
improved, I also received allegations of continuing ill-treatment by
prison officials and the continuing transfers of prisoners to prisons in
remote areas, often without their prior notification and without proper
notification of family members.
Of particular concern is the
information I received of remaining prisoners of conscience being held
not only in Insein but also in other prisons; information which was also
conveyed during my meeting with released prisoners. I therefore
reiterate that the Government should release all remaining prisoners of
conscience without conditions and without delay. This is a central and
necessary step towards national reconciliation and would greatly benefit
Myanmar’s efforts towards democracy. I am keenly aware that there are
continuing discrepancies in the numbers of remaining prisoners of
conscience from different sources. A comprehensive and thorough
investigation is needed to clarify records and determine accurate
numbers. I therefore encourage the Government to consider this issue
urgently, including with the assistance of the international community
as necessary.
Also of significance are the many legislative
reforms that have been undertaken or are underway, including the
adoption of the Labour Organizations Law and the Peaceful Demonstration
and Gathering Law, as well as the amendment to the Political Party
Registration Law. In this respect, I am encouraged that the Parliament
has been active in this legislative reform process. During my mission, I
was informed that the process of drafting a revised Prisons Act, a new
media law – the Printing Press and Publications Law, and a new social
security law, among others, were currently underway. At the same time, I
note concerns regarding some of the provisions in the newly-adopted
legislation, particularly the Peaceful Demonstration and Gathering Law,
and in draft laws, particularly the Printing Press and Publications Law,
which I will elaborate upon more fully in my upcoming report. I also
note concerns regarding the lack of adequate consultation with relevant
stakeholders, including civil society, on some of the draft laws being
prepared. Another concern is the insufficient attention being paid to
ensure the effective implementation of the newly-promulgated and
reformed laws. This can be attributed to, among other factors, the slow
pace in establishing the necessary implementing regulations and
procedures, and the lack of corresponding capacity of institutions to
implement.
There is also a lack of clarity and progress on
reviewing and reforming the laws that I have previously identified as
not in full compliance with international human rights standards, such
as the State Protection Law, the Electronic Transactions Law and the
Unlawful Associations Act. These laws impinge upon a broad range of
human rights and have been used to convict prisoners of conscience.
During my mission, I addressed this issue with the Attorney General.
While I welcome the assurances given that the Government is taking
serious and gradual steps to reform these laws, I reiterate that this
process should be accelerated.
Regardless of efforts made to
reform legislation, an independent, impartial and effective judiciary
within the powers of the Constitution is needed to uphold the rule of
law and act as a last guarantor for safeguarding fundamental freedoms
and human rights in Myanmar. The judiciary is also essential for
Myanmar’s transition to democracy and should play an important role in
ensuring checks and balances on the executive and the legislative. I
have previously expressed concerns regarding the judiciary, and I remain
concerned with its lack of independence and impartiality. In my meeting
with the Chief Justice and other justices of the Supreme Court, there
was little acknowledgement of any challenges and gaps, and a lack of
willingness to address my previous recommendations. I therefore strongly
call on the judiciary to take a proactive approach to apply laws in a
way that would safeguard and guarantee fundamental freedoms and human
rights in line with the Constitution and with international human rights
standards. In this regard, I urge the judiciary to seek technical
assistance from the international community, particularly the Office of
the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) and other
organizations.
During the mission, I also had the opportunity to
engage with members of the National Human Rights Commission for the
first time since its establishment by Presidential Decree in September
last year. I was informed of some actions undertaken by the Commission,
including prison visits, visits to internally displaced persons (IDPs)
in Kachin State, and the receipt and review of complaints from citizens.
I was encouraged to hear that the resources available to the Commission
may be increased significantly, including an increase in the number of
staff supporting its work.
Despite these positive
developments, I am concerned that there are no indications as yet that
the Commission is fully independent and effective in compliance with the
Paris Principles. At present, it seems that the Commission cannot fully
guarantee human rights protection for all in Myanmar. I was informed
that the Commission’s draft rules of procedure were being examined by
the judiciary, and were awaiting the approval of the Council of
Ministers. This sends the wrong signal that the Commission is not fully
independent from the Government. Also, I was informed that its prison
visits were dependent on presidential authorization. Moreover, while the
President appointed Commission members representing different ethnic
minority groups, the vast majority of the Commissioners are retired
government civil servants. And some informed me that they were neither
consulted nor informed in advance of their appointment. There also
doesn’t seem to be clarity on its procedures, including for handling
complaints and conducting prison visits. In this respect, I was informed
that interviews were conducted in the presence of prison officials.
There
is clearly a strong need to enhance the technical and substantive
capacity of the Commissioners and its staff on human rights issues. I
welcome the willingness of the Commission to seek training and technical
assistance from OHCHR and the international community as a whole on the
Paris Principles and other important substantive areas, such as
handling human rights complaints and prison monitoring.
I have
stated previously and continue to believe that the upcoming by-elections
on 1 April will be a key test of how far the Government has progressed
in its process of reform. It is therefore essential that they are truly
free, fair, inclusive and transparent. During my meeting with the Union
Election Commission, I noted that developments, such as the easing of
media restrictions and the revision of the Political Party Registration
Law, resulting in the re-registration of a number of political parties,
including the National League for Democracy, and the decision of some to
contest the by-elections, may allow for the organization of more
credible elections. And I was informed that the use of international
observers was under consideration.
While I was given assurances
by the Chair of the Union Election Commission that the by-elections
will be free and fair, I must stress that the credibility of the
elections will not be determined solely on the day of the vote, but on
the basis of the entire process leading up to and following election
day. Thus, reports I received of campaign irregularities and
restrictions on the ability of political parties to carry out campaign
activities should be addressed seriously by the Union Election
Commission. Additionally, lessons should be learned from the 2010
elections, and problems such as the high cost of registration, the use
of advance votes, and the procedures and costs for filing a complaint
should be addressed as a matter of priority. Further, respect for the
freedoms of expression, assembly and association should be ensured.
Also
during my mission, I was informed about the various measures undertaken
to address Myanmar’s longstanding development challenges, including
economic and financial reforms, and initiatives such as the conference
on development policy options organized by the Government and the United
Nations Country Team. Parliament was also discussing the budget, which
proposes to increase spending in health and education. While I welcome
the Government’s commitment to socio-economic development and poverty
reduction, many challenges remain and the situation is still dire.
Concerns regarding the availability and accessibility of education and
health care were specifically highlighted, as well as the need for the
teaching of ethnic minority languages in schools in minority areas.
Concerns regarding land confiscations and land grabbing, often without
meaningful consultation of affected communities and any or adequate
compensation, as well as the granting of economic concessions for energy
or infrastructure projects without adequate environmental assessments
done, were also brought to my attention. In this regard, I renew my
call on the Government to ensure not only the realization, but also the
protection of basic economic, social and cultural rights. These are
fundamental rights that are equally essential to Myanmar’s democratic
transition, national reconciliation and its long-term stability.
Concerns
regarding the ongoing tensions and conflict with armed ethnic groups in
border areas, particularly in Kachin State, were consistently raised
during my mission. I received continuing allegations of serious human
rights violations committed during conflict, including attacks against
civilian populations, extrajudicial killings, sexual violence, internal
displacement, land confiscations, the use of human shields, the
recruitment of child soldiers, as well as forced labour and portering.
And I must emphasize that I received reports of violations being
committed by all parties to the conflict. While I welcome the
Government’s commitment to peace talks and the progress made in this
regard, such as the agreements reached with various groups, including
most recently, the Mon, it is vital that these allegations and reports
be urgently addressed. I was informed that action had been taken on some
cases involving military personnel, but much more needs to be done. It
is also vital that the authorities and all armed groups ensure the
protection of civilians in conflict-affected areas.
I must also
emphasize that the needs of those displaced and affected by the conflict
must be addressed as a matter of priority. In this regard, it is
important that the United Nations and its humanitarian partners have
regular, independent and predictable access to all individuals, in
particular IDPs, in need of humanitarian assistance, regardless of
whether they are in Government or non-Government controlled areas.
Further, delivery of humanitarian assistance under the United Nations
umbrella cannot be linked to ongoing negotiations between the Government
and armed groups or be made conditional to the Government’s assistance
to people in non-Government controlled areas.
More broadly,
efforts towards finding a durable political solution to the conflict
must be accelerated and are essential for broader national
reconciliation. These must address the root causes of the conflict,
including systematic discrimination, displacement and economic
deprivation affecting ethnic minorities. I therefore renew my call to
the Government to develop a comprehensive plan to officially engage
ethnic minority groups in serious and inclusive dialogue to resolve
long-standing grievances and deep-rooted concerns. The Government should
ensure that ethnic minorities are granted fundamental rights. This
includes the Rohingya community.
Finally, I remain of the firm
conviction that justice and accountability measures, as well as measures
to ensure access to the truth, are fundamental for Myanmar to move
forward towards national reconciliation. During my mission, I made a
careful assessment as to whether the National Human Rights Commission
could play a role in this regard. However, considering the lack of
independence and the limited capacity of the Commission, it is crucially
important that the Government of Myanmar involve stakeholders,
including victims of human rights violations, in order to get their
advice and views on how and when to establish truth, justice and
accountability measures. It is also important to learn lessons from
other countries that have experience in these processes.
I
heard from many interlocutors about the importance of moving forward.
But I must stress that moving forward cannot ignore or whitewash what
happened in the past. Thus, facing Myanmar’s own recent history and
acknowledging the violations that people have suffered, will be
necessary to ensure national reconciliation and to prevent future
violations from occurring.
To conclude, I have previously stated
that the steps taken by the Government had the potential to bring about
an improvement in the human rights situation in Myanmar and deepen its
transition to democracy. My mission confirmed that a positive impact has
been made; however serious challenges remain and must be addressed.
There is also a risk of backtracking on the progress achieved thus far.
Therefore, at this crucial moment in the country’s history, further and
sustained action should be taken to bring about further change. Prior to
its assumption of the Chairpersonship of ASEAN in 2014, I would
encourage Myanmar to demonstrate concrete progress in improving its
human rights situation. The international community should remain
engaged and should support and assist the Government during this
important time.
I want to again thank the Government of Myanmar
for its invitation and cooperation. I look forward to another visit to
the country before my next report to the General Assembly in October
2012. I reaffirm my willingness to work constructively and cooperatively
with Myanmar to improve the human rights situation of its people.Media agencies